Trees Across the Road: Thurston v. Wright (1889)
Scope
This entry follows one lawsuit from Benzie County as the Michigan Supreme Court reported it in October 1889 [1]. The facts below are the court's summary of the trial record, mostly as set out in Chief Justice Sherwood's opinion. The opinion does not name the township or say where the road ran. It also does not say how the case ended after a new trial was ordered. The court did not decide whether the road was a legal highway, and neither does this entry.
The road and the arrest
The quarrel began over "a highway running across Mrs. Thurston's land." Charles T. Wright claimed the road had been established "by user for a period of 10 years or more." Myron E. Thurston denied that it had [1, pp. 96, 98]. Wright used the road to haul logs "from the woods to manufacture into lumber, in common with others." Thurston and his hired men then "slashed and felled large trees across the track," which, the opinion says, "completely obstructed it for the passage of teams and loads" [1, p. 98].
Wright consulted attorneys, the prosecuting attorney and the justice of the peace. He was told the facts made a proper case, and he swore to an affidavit the justice had drawn. He also presented four affidavits from citizens living near the road, stating that it had been used as a public highway for ten years or more [1, pp. 98-100]. Thurston was arrested for obstructing the alleged highway and pleaded "Not guilty." A jury was struck, and the case was adjourned for ten days. Before that date the prosecuting attorney said the case would not be tried, and it was dismissed. No bail had been required [1, pp. 98-99].
The verdict
Thurston then sued Wright for false imprisonment and malicious prosecution. In the Benzie circuit, before Judge Aldrich, a jury awarded him $300 [1, pp. 97-99]. Wright appealed. The opinion says it was "substantially conceded that the complaint and warrant did not state an offense," and that the question of damages was "the principal one in the case" [1, p. 101].
Reversal, and a split court
All five justices agreed to reverse. The Chief Justice found errors in the evidence at trial:
- The jury should have heard the justice of the peace answer whether Wright had shown "maliciousness or over-anxiety to prosecute."
- The prosecutor's letter authorizing the prosecution should have been admitted.
- Thurston should have been required to state the exact sum he paid a witness, Morgan.
- A disputed log-hauling arrangement involving a witness named Shea should have been kept out [1, pp. 100-101].
The judgment was "set aside, and a new trial granted" [1, p. 102].
The justices divided on two other points. Chief Justice Sherwood, joined by Justice Campbell, thought the trial judge "went too far" in telling the jury it could weigh Wright's expressions of ill feeling. He also thought the judge should have given Wright's requested instructions. Under them, Wright was not liable for false imprisonment if he had merely laid the facts before the justice after taking advice [1, pp. 101-102].
Justice Champlin disagreed on both points, and Justices Morse and Long concurred with him [1, pp. 102-104]. In his view, once "an act has been done,—such as instituting a prosecution," expressions of ill feeling "become relevant upon the question of malice." He held the requested instructions defective because they omitted two elements. Wright had to have made "a full and fair statement of all the facts known to him" to the prosecutor and his own attorney, and he had to have "acted upon such advice in good faith" [1, p. 103]. Champlin concurred in reversing "upon the other points" [1, p. 104].
With three of the five justices, Champlin's view controlled on malice and the instructions. The reporter's headnotes state it as the rule [1, p. 97]. Sherwood's opinion controlled on the evidence questions. The outcome of any retrial is not known.
Single published opinion. Township and road location are not named; the court did not decide whether the road was a highway; the retrial outcome is unknown.
Sources
- Thurston v. Wright, 77 Mich. 96 (Michigan Supreme Court, opinion of Sherwood, C.J., separate opinion of Champlin, J.; Michigan Reports, vol. 77, pp. 96–104; official bound volume hosted by the Michigan Courts, argued April 18, decided October 25, 1889). Printed pp. 96–104 used (PDF pages 126–134 of the scan). Official scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14
Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.