Northern Knowledge Library

A small, cited encyclopedia of northern Michigan local history and farm knowledge

Lumber at Masts Mill: Solomon v. Richardson, 1915–1919

Published · 1 cited source

County: Oscoda County

Scope and source

This entry follows one lumber contract in Oscoda County, as told in a single source: the Michigan Supreme Court's opinion in Solomon v. Richardson, decided October 6, 1919 [1, p. 416]. The court summarized the trial testimony selectively, for a legal question about damages. Its account is not a full record of what happened in the woods. The opinion does not say what the lumber was finally used for or name any dam. It does not report how the case ended after the court sent it back for a new trial. Oscoda here means the county, which the opinion names directly as the location of the delivery site.

The contract

On December 18, 1915, the court wrote, Selig Solomon and Frank H. Richardson entered into a written contract. Solomon agreed to deliver to Richardson "at Masts Mill, near Mio, Oscoda county, 100,000 feet of sawed lumber at $20 a thousand" [1, p. 416]. The principal item was 1,020 pieces of piling; the rest was special "bill stuff." Delivery was due on or before February 15, 1916 [1, p. 416].

According to the testimony as the court described it, Solomon knew at or before the contract was made that the lumber "was going to the Eastern Michigan Power Company." An agent of that company was with Richardson at his first talk with Solomon about the lumber. Richardson later prepared the contract "in his own name," telling Solomon that he had an order from the company [1, p. 418]. The court added that it did not appear Richardson had a contract with the company, a particular price, a delivery date, or that the lumber was to be used "for any special purpose other than its dimensions would indicate" [1, p. 418].

The breakdown

Solomon began delivering about the middle of January 1916 and continued until February 11. On that date, the court wrote, "a controversy arose between the parties over the inspection and rejection of certain timber" [1, p. 416]. They could not agree how much should be rejected. Solomon told Richardson he would not complete the contract, then sued for the price of what he had delivered [1, p. 416]. The opinion does not say which timbers were rejected or whose view of their quality was right.

The trial and the appeal

The case was tried before the judge without a jury. The trial court found that Richardson was entitled to $1,481.06 in damages for nondelivery. After subtracting Solomon's credit of $418.84, it entered judgment for Richardson for $1,062.22 [1, p. 416].

Over Solomon's objection, Richardson had been allowed to show that he went several miles from the delivery point to buy the rest of the timber. He put his total expenses at $1,695.81 [1, p. 417]. That figure, the court noted, included the purchase price, interest on money used to buy the timber, interest on profits of his that the opinion describes as withheld by the Eastern Michigan Power Company, car demurrage, travel costs looking for timber, and "the expense of six idle teams held in the woods several days waiting for the timber to be cut" [1, p. 417]. These were Richardson's claimed costs, not amounts the Supreme Court approved.

The Supreme Court held that the trial court should have used the ordinary measure of damages: the difference between the contract price and the market price at the time and place of delivery [1, pp. 417, 419]. The trial judge had found that such timber was difficult to obtain near Masts Mill. The Supreme Court said it could find no testimony to support that conclusion [1, p. 418]. Richardson's claimed contract with the power company "was not produced, and the testimony in relation to it was subsequently stricken out" [1, p. 418]. There was also no showing that the place of delivery lacked a market price [1, p. 419].

The judgment was "reversed and a new trial ordered," with costs of the Supreme Court to Solomon [1, p. 419].

Where the record ends

The opinion does not decide who was right about the rejected timber, or how much either man owed. It also does not show what happened at any new trial. Those questions would need trial records or later filings, which were not examined for this entry.

Single source: this entry rests on one court opinion, which summarized the trial testimony selectively for a question about damages. It is not a full record of what happened.

Sources

  1. Selig Solomon v. Frank H. Richardson, 207 Mich. 415 (Michigan Supreme Court, opinion of Bird, C.J.; Michigan Reports, vol. 207, pp. 415–419, Richard W. Cooper, reporter, Chicago: Callaghan & Company, 1920; official scan hosted by the Michigan Courts, submitted June 11, decided October 6, 1919). Printed pp. 415–419 used (PDF pages 439–443 of the scan). Official scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15

Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.