Onaway on the Sanborn Maps: Reading the 1907 and 1915 Fire Insurance Atlases
Scope
This entry describes what two Sanborn Map Company fire insurance atlases of Onaway show: a four-sheet set dated September 1907 and a five-sheet set dated October 1915, both held by the Library of Congress. It reports the map labels, with context from the cited sources. Each dated edition records selected information for insurers; the Library of Congress describes the month and year printed on small-town sheets as its publication date [3], so this entry does not treat those dates as survey dates. A map does not show when a business opened or closed, or why.
What a Sanborn map is
The Library of Congress explains that fire insurance maps use a detailed set of symbols, and that they "were made for a very specific use." The insurance industry chose what was mapped and how, so knowing the keys and colors is essential to reading them [3]. Onaway's 1915 sheets carry their own key. On it, buildings colored yellow are frame, red brick, blue stone, gray iron and brown fireproof. Other symbols mark things such as fire walls, iron doors, steam boilers and automatic sprinklers [2]. Many of the industrial buildings shown on these sheets are colored yellow, which the 1915 key defines as frame construction [1][2].
The title circles
Each atlas opens with a circular title block. The 1907 block gives Onaway's population as 2,800, lists prevailing winds from the west and northwest, and records "No steam & no hand engine," two independent hose carts and one hook and ladder truck [1]. The 1915 block gives a population of 2,750 and lists three hand hose carts and one two-wheel hook and ladder cart [2]. These are the figures the mapmakers printed. This entry did not check them against a census. A local history reproduced by the Onaway Historical Museum gives a different, earlier figure, "some 3,000" people by 1903 [4].
The Lobdell plant on both atlases
Both atlases label the large wood-products plant as jointly occupied by two named companies. The 1907 sheet 4 labels it "The Lobdell & Churchill Mf'g Co. & The American Wood Rim Co., occupied jointly." Its lumber yard carries the note "average amount of lumber on hand 3 million feet" [1]. On the 1915 sheet 5 the label reads "The Lobdell Emery Mf'g Co. & The American Wood Rim Co. (Occupied Jointly)," and the yard note reads 3½ million feet [2]. The two indexes match. The 1907 index lists "American Wood Rim Co." and "Lobdell & Churchhill Mfg. Co." on sheet 4, and the 1915 index lists "American Wood Rim Co." and "Lobdell Emery M'f'g Co." on sheet 5 [1][2]. The 1907 index and sheet spell the partner's name differently. The maps alone do not say when or why the partner company's name changed.
Mills "not in use"
The maps also record whether some mills were running. On the 1907 sheet 1, the M.S. Cate saw and planing mills are labeled "not in operation" [1]. On the 1915 sheet 1, the Gardner-Peterman & Co. stave and heading mill, its hot-air dry kiln, and its separate saw mill are all marked "not in use." A note records one night watchman for the stave and heading mills, the saw mill and the yards [2]. In 1907 the same firm appears in the index as "Gardner-Peterman & Co., Mills & Yard" [1]. The 1907 atlas records the Cate mills as not in operation; the 1915 atlas records these Gardner-Peterman mills as not in use. Those annotations do not establish whether the inactivity was temporary or permanent.
Other businesses in the indexes
The indexes list other named businesses and buildings. The 1907 list includes the Onaway Iron Works, H. Deane's iron works, the Fusee Bros. planing mill, the City Water Works, and a "D. & M. R.R. Depot" [1]. The 1907 sheets label the line running through town the Detroit & Mackinaw Railroad [1]. The 1915 index lists the Onaway Elevator Co., A.E. Starks's elevator, M. Chandler's shingle mill and the Standard Oil Co., as well as hotels, churches and schools [2]. Because the two atlases cover the town differently, with four sheets in 1907 and five in 1915, a business missing from one index is not proof that it had closed.
Using the maps
Both atlases are free to view in full at the Library of Congress, which states that its online Sanborn collection is in the public domain [3]. They are best used alongside written sources. In the American Wood Rim story, for example, the maps explicitly record joint occupancy. They do not establish legal ownership or report wages or the later 1926 fire.
Corrections
On November 7, 2026, the day it was first published, this entry was corrected after an independent review. It now says the maps label the Lobdell plant as jointly occupied, not jointly owned. It no longer says that written accounts describe the joint occupancy, and it no longer says that most industrial buildings were frame. It keeps the 1907 and 1915 mill annotations distinct and treats printed map dates as publication dates.
Related entries
Sources
- “Sanborn Fire Insurance Map from Onaway, Presque Isle County, Michigan (September 1907, 4 sheets).” Sanborn Map Company; Library of Congress, Geography and Map Division, September 1907. Library of Congress item · Archived copy ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8
- “Sanborn Fire Insurance Map from Onaway, Presque Isle County, Michigan (October 1915, 5 sheets).” Sanborn Map Company; Library of Congress, Geography and Map Division, October 1915. Library of Congress item · Archived copy ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7
- “Sanborn Maps: About this Collection (with Rights & Access).” Library of Congress, Geography and Map Division, undated web page, read November 7, 2026. Collection page · Archived copy ↩1 ↩2 ↩3
- Lamb, Richard. “Onaway, Michigan: The First 50 Years.” Onaway Outlook (Presque Isle Advance), July 1999; reproduced by the Onaway Historical Museum as “The History of Onaway”. Original article · Archived copy ↩
Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.