Tolls at the Cheboygan Dam: Nelson v. Cheboygan Slack-water Navigation Company (1880)
Scope
This entry rests on one source: the Michigan Supreme Court's reported decision in Nelson v. Cheboygan Slack-water Navigation Company, 44 Mich. 7–12 (1880) [1]. It reports what the court decided on the record before it. The report does not name the plaintiffs beyond "Ephraim Nelson et al.," locate their mill, give the toll rates, or say what became of the dam.
The dam and the waters behind it
The plaintiffs sued to recover money they had paid under protest as tolls for passing through a canal. The canal ran around a dam the company had built "across the Cheboygan river about a mile above its mouth," where there had been rapids [1, p. 8]. Justice Cooley began with geography. In the court's description, the Cheboygan runs eight miles from Mullett Lake to "Mackinaw straits" and is the outlet for a chain of lakes and rivers, including Burt, Crooked and Black lakes. Two small steamers ran from the head of Crooked Lake to the straits, and all these waters carried logs and lumber [1, p. 8].
In 1847, the court said, "one McLeod" built a lower dam on the same site. "The case does not show how or why McLeod came to build this dam," nor how the company came to hold the site [1, pp. 8–9]. An 1867 act provided for slack-water navigation companies on rivers in four counties, Cheboygan among them. The company was organized the next year and built its dam [1, p. 9].
The plaintiffs' case
The plaintiffs' evidence tended to show that they owned a mill above the dam and used a tug and lighters. In 1876 the tug made 116 trips each way. That year they sent 7,596,000 feet of lumber over the Cheboygan's waters, part on lighters and the rest on rafts. The dam, they said, blocked vessels and rafts, so they had to use the canal, and they paid tolls "amounting in all to $2767.70." Without a dam, they said, their empty lighters could have gone upstream and their rafts could have run down [1, pp. 9–10].
What the court decided
The court followed an earlier decision, Benjamin v. Manistee River Co. That case held that the state could let companies improve navigable rivers and charge tolls, despite the Ordinance of 1787's promise that those waters would be "forever free" [1, p. 10]. Cooley remarked that the 1867 act, which set no limit on tolls, was "probably inoperative." A toll schedule was fixed by law in 1871 [1, p. 9].
The plaintiffs argued that no toll could be charged for traffic that could have used the river before the dam. The court declined to decide that: "We do not think the broad question which the plaintiffs attempt to raise is in the case." No one had tried to show at trial that the improvement did not help the plaintiffs' traffic. On this record, the tolls were proper whether the benefits were created by the dam or "only enhanced by it" [1, p. 11].
The plaintiffs also said the company was McLeod's successor and bound by any duty he had to keep a free passage. The court found that no such legislation had been shown at trial and that the company was not shown to be McLeod's assign [1, pp. 11–12].
The plaintiffs argued, finally, that the dam had been built without the consent of the county board of supervisors. The court left that question open. It had not been raised below, and "we neither know what the fact was, nor could we act upon it if we did. We sit here to review only the rulings of the circuit judge" [1, p. 12]. The judgment for the company was affirmed with costs [1, p. 12].
Single source: one court opinion deciding only the questions raised at trial. The plaintiffs' account is their evidence, not findings.
Sources
- Ephraim Nelson et al. v. The Cheboygan Slack-water Navigation Company, 44 Mich. 7 (Michigan Supreme Court, opinion of Cooley, J.; Michigan Reports, vol. 44, pp. 7–12, Henry A. Chaney, state reporter; official scan hosted by the Michigan Courts, decided June 11, 1880). Printed pp. 7–12 used (PDF pages 31–36 of the scan). Official scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12
Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.