A Right to Build a Dock: Munro v. Meech (1893)
Scope
This entry follows one Michigan Supreme Court decision about a deed to lakefront land at South Arm, in Charlevoix County [1, pp. 596-597]. It relies only on the published opinion, which does not date the deed. It does not say whether a dock was ever built, or how the case ended after the court ordered a new trial. No deed, plat or later court record was read.
The deed
The opinion explains that a man named Cole owned "a piece of land bordering on a lake in the village of South Arm, Charlevoix county." Cole executed an instrument to John Munro, and the court quoted its material parts [1, pp. 596-597]. The deed describes a parcel of at least 120 by 120 feet. It was to front on "the south arm of Pine lake" and on "a street to be laid out," on fraction six of section 23, township 32 north, range 7 west. Its northern line ran at "an ash tree, which stands nearly equidistant from a warehouse upon the above-described premises, and a blacksmith shop" on neighboring land [1, p. 597].
For ten dollars, Cole quitclaimed to Munro "and to his heirs and assigns, forever, the right to build and use a dock upon the front of the above-described land." The grant was measured from "the most south-eastern pile now driven in the water" out "to the center of the channel of said lake." The deed added that "The above right to include all the rights of the said party of the first part south and east of said lines" [1, p. 597]. The land was later platted as lots 1 and 2 of block A of the village of South Arm [1, p. 598].
The lawsuit
Marceline Munro sued in ejectment. She claimed title through conveyances from John Munro and alleged that she owned the land itself in fee. The defendants were in possession. They claimed under a deed from the assignee of John Munro, "an insolvent debtor" [1, p. 598]. The case came up on the defendants' writ of error from Charlevoix (Ramsdell, J.) [1, p. 596].
What the court decided
Justice Grant wrote the opinion. He called the deed's construction "the principal question in the case" and said its intent must be gathered from "the four corners" of the instrument. A right may require "the permanent and exclusive use of the land," he wrote, "but this will not operate to convey the fee." He quoted Chief Justice Shaw of Massachusetts: such a right of use is "an easement or franchise, and not a right of property in the soil" [1, p. 598].
The deed recited that Cole owned the fee, but it "expressly conveys only the right to build and use a dock." The court likened it to a railroad right of way [1, pp. 598-599]. It read the clause about "all the rights" as referring only to the dock right. The plaintiff had therefore "failed to prove the title set forth in the declaration." The trial court had erred in admitting the deed and in refusing to direct a verdict for the defendants [1, p. 599].
"In view of possible further litigation," the court also addressed two other points. Oral evidence could show that an earlier suit, pleaded in bar, had not been decided on its merits. A bona fide purchaser from an assignee who never filed the statutory bond would be protected if neither the assignor nor the creditors objected and the assignee went on to execute the trust. Munro's assignment to Henry A. Harmon was dated December 4, 1883 [1, pp. 599-600].
The judgment was "reversed, and new trial ordered." Chief Justice Hooker and Justices McGrath and Montgomery concurred. Justice Long did not sit [1, p. 600]. The decision is dated February 10, 1893 [1, p. 596]. No later outcome is known.
Single published opinion. The deed is undated, nothing shows a dock was built, and no outcome after the new trial is known.
Sources
- Munro v. Meech, 94 Mich. 596 (Michigan Supreme Court, opinion of Grant, J.; Michigan Reports, vol. 94, pp. 596–600; official bound volume hosted by the Michigan Courts, argued January 13, decided February 10, 1893). Printed pp. 596–600 used (PDF pages 654–658 of the scan). Official scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13
Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.