Northern Knowledge Library

A small, cited encyclopedia of northern Michigan local history and farm knowledge

The First Known Nest of Kirtland's Warbler, Oscoda County, 1903

Published · 2 cited sources

County: Oscoda County

Scope

This entry rests on Norman A. Wood's report "Discovery of the Breeding Area of Kirtland's Warbler," the lead article in the Bulletin of the Michigan Ornithological Club, volume V, number 1, March 1904 [1, p. 3]. Wood wrote from the University Museum, University of Michigan [1, p. 13]. A shorter note by Edward Arnold in the same volume describes a nest found in 1904 [2, p. 67]. Everything here is Wood's or Arnold's own account. No other record of the trip was read, and nothing here describes the bird's later history or present range. During the same trip Wood also found a second nest, which his report places in Crawford County [1, p. 11]. That nest is outside this entry, which stays with Oscoda County.

A bird nobody recognized

Wood says that early in June 1903 the Museum assistant, E. H. Frothingham, and a friend, T. G. Gale, went to Oscoda County to fish the Au Sable River. Frothingham heard a song he did not know, and Gale shot the bird. Back at the museum the skin proved to be a male Kirtland's warbler. Its label read "4 mile plains north of the Au Sable. T. G. Gale, June 15th, 1903." Frothingham told Wood the birds were "there in some numbers and in full song," and added, "I never thought of its being Kirtland's Warbler" [1, p. 3].

Wood took the train to Roscommon on June 29 [1, p. 3] and then rowed down the Au Sable. He reached the Butler Bridge, "a new steel structure over the Au Sable in Oscoda county," after a trip of "sixty miles" by water [1, p. 5]. On July 2 he climbed onto the "Norway" plains above the river and shot "a fine adult male" of the species, but found neither the female nor a nest [1, p. 5]; [1, p. 6].

July 8, 1903

On July 8 Wood drove out with J. A. Parmalee, who had been with Gale when the June bird was shot [1, p. 7]. About five miles on they reached a tract of several hundred acres that, a resident told Wood, had burned about six years before. Young jack pine three to ten feet high grew among burnt stubs, with sweetfern, blueberry and trailing arbutus on the ground [1, p. 8]. Wood writes that "We had nearly reached the line of Crawford county" when he heard a song. He shot that male. Half a mile farther on he watched another male carry a worm to a dead tree near the road, and then flushed the female from the ground. "It may be imagined with what delight I beheld the first nest of this rare bird ever seen," he wrote. It held two young, "perhaps ten days old," and one egg, which "proved to be the only egg found" [1, p. 8].

The nest lay in a depression at the foot of a jack pine about five feet tall, only five feet from the road. It was lined with fine dead grass, pine needles and a few horse hairs. The egg measured .72 by .56 inches and held no embryo [1, p. 9]. The photograph of the spot is captioned "Site of the first Known nest of Kirtland's Warbler, Oscoda Co., Mich." [1, p. 4].

Collecting the nest

On July 11 Wood photographed the nest, shot both parents and dug up the nest. He kept the two young alive on houseflies until July 13, when they died, and he made skins of them [1, p. 11]. His list of specimens places the two nestlings of July 13 in Oscoda County [1, p. 13].

Wood's count and his warning

Summing up the trip "in Crawford and Oscoda counties," Wood said he had heard and seen sixteen adults and taken "fifteen birds in all." He estimated the colony at thirteen pairs, or about seventy-eight birds with their young, and sixty-three left after his collecting. He added that "it is hardly probable that I found all the birds in this colony." He believed the birds had nested there only three or four years, since the area burned "about 1897," and he warned that "Next spring another fire is liable to occur" [1, p. 12].

The next year

Writing in the same volume, Edward Arnold reported that on June 15, 1904, he found a nest with four fresh eggs in Oscoda County, "the first set of eggs of this species known to science." He found the birds "ten miles distant from the Au Sable river," which he presented as contrary to Wood's experience [2, p. 67]. Arnold does not say where his nest lay in relation to Wood's.

Wood's and Arnold's own 1904 accounts only. The second 1903 nest (Crawford County) is outside the entry. Nothing on the species' later history or present range.

Sources

  1. Wood, Norman A. “Discovery of the Breeding Area of Kirtland's Warbler.” Bulletin of the Michigan Ornithological Club 5, no. 1, pp. 3–13; Detroit: Michigan Ornithological Club (imprint on the issue cover); Ernst Mayr Library, Museum of Comparative Zoology, Harvard, copy digitized by the Internet Archive, March 1904. Page references are printed page numbers; printed page 3 is PDF page 13, so add 10 to reach the PDF page. Internet Archive scan (PDF) · Internet Archive item · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16
  2. Arnold, Edward. “Nesting of Kirtland's Warbler in Northern Michigan, 1904.” Bulletin of the Michigan Ornithological Club 5, pp. 67–68; same Internet Archive scan as the Wood article, 1904. Printed pages 67 and 68 are PDF pages 89 and 90. Internet Archive scan (PDF) · Internet Archive item · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2

Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.