Northern Knowledge Library

A small, cited encyclopedia of northern Michigan local history and farm knowledge

Charcoal Iron, Hemlock Bark and Seed Potatoes: Kalkaska County's Farms in the 1927 Soil Survey

Published · 1 cited source

County: Kalkaska County

Scope

This entry rests on one report: Soil Survey of Kalkaska County, Michigan, Series 1927, No. 28, by J. O. Veatch, L. R. Schoenmann, Z. C. Foster and F. R. Lesh, published by the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Bureau of Chemistry and Soils with the Michigan Agricultural Experiment Station and the Michigan Department of Conservation [1, title page]. It follows what the report says about how Kalkaska County people made a living, from the side work of the settlement years to the cash and seed crops the surveyors singled out in the 1920s. The report gives no farmers' own accounts, and it names no charcoal furnaces, bark buyers or seed growers. Figures from its crop table were read from the page scan, because the machine-read text garbles several of them. This entry does not follow the county past the report.

Making a living at settlement

According to the report, settlement began in the western part of the county about 1860. "Very few of the early settlers depended entirely on agriculture for a living, as lumbering, the manufacture of charcoal iron, the cutting of hemlock bark for tanning purposes, and trapping were also sources of livelihood" [1, p. 5]. By 1880 the population was only about 2,900. Farming supplied homes and lumber camps with hay, wheat, potatoes and corn. Fields stayed small "on account of the labor involved in removing trees and stumps" [1, p. 5].

Railroad, boom and decline

Large-scale pine lumbering began about 1875, and hardwood lumbering about 1890 [1, p. 2]. The report says the Grand Rapids & Indiana Railway "was extended into the eastern part of the county about 1878" and was followed by large-scale lumbering and more farming [1, p. 5]. Elsewhere it says the same railway "passes through the western and north-central parts of the county" [1, p. 3]. The report does not explain the difference.

From 1880 to 1910 the number of farms and the improved acreage rose fairly steadily. Between 1910 and 1920 both farms and population fell, "following the removal of the larger part of the forests and the beginning of the decline in the lumber industry" [1, p. 5]. The report puts the lumber peak about 1910 [1, p. 3]. The 1920 census counted 5,577 people, and preliminary 1930 figures showed "a marked decrease" [1, p. 2]. In 1927, the surveyors wrote, "the acreage of land being abandoned probably exceeds that being cleared for farms" [1, p. 5].

The turn to cash and seed crops

The report then turns to newer trends. In recent years, it says, farmers had grown more alfalfa and sweetclover and expanded dairying, "the most profitable adjunct of general farming under present economic conditions." There had also been "increased specialization in the growing of cash income crops," which it names as potatoes, beans and seed crops [1, p. 5]. The surveyors expected any further growth to come partly from "the growing of garden vegetable seed and seed potatoes" and from vegetables for local canning factories [1, p. 6].

"Potatoes are the most important cash income crop throughout the county," the report says. It adds that the tubers were of high quality and that "A number of growers specialize in the production of seed potatoes on a large scale." Navy or white beans were also an important cash crop, though grown on small acreages [1, p. 7]. Seed growing was "locally rather important," and the main seed crops were potatoes, red clover, sweetclover, alfalfa and radishes [1, p. 8]. Among livestock, "The principal source of income is from dairy cattle and dairy products" [1, p. 7]; [1, p. 8].

What the crop table shows

The report's Table 2 gives census figures for 1919 and 1924 and state crop-report figures for 1926 [1, p. 6]. Read from the scan:

  • Potatoes: 4,362 acres and 414,581 bushels in 1919; 2,393 acres and 292,604 bushels in 1924; 2,110 acres in 1926. The ten-year average yield was 88.0 bushels an acre.
  • Beans: 253 acres and 2,143 bushels in 1919; 601 acres in 1924, with no bushel figure printed; 640 acres in 1926.
  • Alfalfa: 387 acres in 1919 and 1,539 acres in 1924; a footnote marks the 1924 figure as included in the hay acreage.
  • Rye: 7,117 acres in 1919 and 1,266 acres in 1924.

The table also covers hay, corn, oats, wheat and buckwheat, which are not listed here. Hay was the largest crop by acreage in 1924 and 1926; in 1919 rye had slightly more acres.

The table shows less land in potatoes in 1924 and 1926 than in 1919. The report's text does not comment on this, and the table does not separate seed potatoes from other potatoes. Beans and alfalfa, by contrast, grew. Rye, which had more acres than any other grain in 1919, fell sharply.

A puzzle the surveyors left open

The report ends its account of farming on a puzzle. "A surprising diversity of crops can be grown in Kalkaska County with fair yields and a good quality of products," it says, "yet at this time (1927) less than 25 per cent of the land has been improved for agricultural purposes and 30 per cent of the farmed land has been abandoned." The surveyors did not try to explain it. They wrote that "The causes for this condition and the economic factors to be considered are hardly within the scope of a soil survey report" [1, p. 8].

Single 1927 federal-state soil survey. No furnaces, bark buyers or seed growers named. Table figures read from the scan. Two statements on the railway's route. Nothing after the report.

Sources

  1. Veatch, J. O., L. R. Schoenmann, Z. C. Foster and F. R. Lesh. “Soil Survey of Kalkaska County, Michigan.” U.S. Department of Agriculture, Bureau of Chemistry and Soils, Series 1927, No. 28; USDA National Agricultural Library collection, digitized by the Internet Archive, survey series 1927; printed by the U.S. Government Printing Office, 1931. Page references are printed page numbers; add 2 to reach the PDF page. Internet Archive scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18

Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.