Northern Knowledge Library

A small, cited encyclopedia of northern Michigan local history and farm knowledge

The Hillman Hall Fire and the Insurance Suit, 1929 to 1931

Published · 2 cited sources

County: Montmorency County

Scope

This entry rests mainly on one source: the Michigan Supreme Court's opinion in Hillman Township Board v. Empire Mutual Fire Insurance Co., decided February 27, 1931, and printed in volume 253 of the Michigan Reports [1, p. 394]; [1, p. 395]. What it says about the fire comes from the court's summary of what each side claimed and offered as evidence at trial. How the fire started was disputed, and the opinion does not settle that question, so this entry does not either. The opinion's heading reads "Error to Montmorency" [1, p. 395], and it names no county beyond that. For Hillman's county, this entry relies on an 1893 Michigan Supreme Court opinion, which says: "The county of Montmorency is composed of the six townships of Albert, Briley, Hillman, Montmorency, Rust, and Wheatfield" [2, p. 40]. No newspaper accounts were read. The opinion gives no dollar amounts and mentions no injuries.

The hall and its insurance

The opinion says a hall at Hillman, Michigan, burned on June 5, 1929 [1, p. 395]; [1, p. 397]. Empire Mutual Fire Insurance Company had issued two policies on it, one to the township board of Hillman township and one to Hillman township, so both sued [1, p. 395]. One policy described "The two story, stucco frame, metal roof building used as the town's officers' offices, hall and voting place." The other described "the two-story, metal roof, stucco, frame building used as a hall." The company's agent, John Pettinger, wrote both and testified that he knew the building [1, p. 396].

Two accounts of the fire

The insurer said that at the time of the fire "a picture show was being operated in the building" in violation of a 1913 law. It also said a motion picture machine had been run "by an incompetent person, in violation of law" [1, p. 395]. Its theory at trial was that the films had caught fire and started the blaze [1, p. 396].

The township side told a different story. Its evidence tended to show that the fire began in the attic and that the steel ceiling grew so hot "the paint began to fall off" [1, p. 396]. The moving-picture part of the program, it said, had ended some time before the fire was found. All but two of the films were in metal containers. Those two lay on a table, caught fire from embers falling from the attic, and were put out with a chemical extinguisher. The fire then burned through the roof. The township's evidence also tended to show that "the water pressure was off by reason of the repair of the water mains in the village," so people could not get water on the fire "until it was too late" [1, p. 397]. The court summed up: "Defendant claims the picture films caused the fire. Plaintiffs claim the fire burned the building and contents, including the picture films" [1, p. 397].

What the court decided

A 1921 law, Act No. 264, barred an insurer from voiding a policy for breach of a condition unless it had been injured by the breach, or the loss had occurred during the breach and by reason of it. The court said that law was in force on June 5, 1929, "although it is said to have been repealed" by the 1929 insurance code. The repeal did not take effect until August 28, 1929, after the parties' rights were fixed [1, p. 397]; [1, p. 398]. That put the burden on the insurer to show a causal link between any breach and the loss. The jury decided "this disputed question of fact in favor of plaintiffs," and the court held itself bound by that finding [1, p. 398].

When the case was called for trial, the insurer asked to move it elsewhere, citing hostile public feeling it had learned of from newspaper comment. The court found no abuse of discretion in refusing [1, p. 398]. It asked: "If, where human liberty is involved, a reading of newspapers is not sufficient to disqualify a juror, how, in a civil case, can it amount to a disqualification?" [1, p. 399]. Because the agent knew how the building was used and the policies described it as a hall, its use as a public hall was within the policies [1, p. 396]; [1, p. 399]. Justice Potter wrote that the judgment for the township was "affirmed, with costs," and the rest of the court concurred [1, p. 400].

Rests mainly on one published opinion. The fire's cause was disputed and is not decided here; the jury decided only the causal link the 1921 statute required. Hillman's county rests on an 1893 opinion listing Montmorency's townships. No amounts, no injuries, no newspapers read.

Sources

  1. Hillman Township Board v. Empire Mutual Fire Insurance Co., 253 Mich. 394 (Michigan Supreme Court, opinion of Potter, J.; Michigan Reports, vol. 253, pp. 394–400, Richard W. Cooper, reporter, Chicago: Callaghan and Company, 1932; official scan hosted by the Michigan Courts, submitted January 16, decided February 27, 1931). Printed pp. 394–400 used (PDF pages 430–436 of the scan). Official scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20
  2. Thomas Double v. James H. McQueen, Andrew Dickie, and William W. Murphy, 96 Mich. 39 (Michigan Supreme Court, opinion of Long, J.; Michigan Reports, vol. 96, pp. 39–46, William D. Fuller, reporter, Chicago: Callaghan & Co., 1893; official scan hosted by the Michigan Courts, argued May 31, decided June 7, 1893). Printed p. 40 used (PDF page 96 of the scan). Official scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩

Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.