Lumber Town or Steamboat Stop? Glen Haven in the National Register, 1983 and 1990
Scope
This entry reports what one National Register file says about the Glen Haven Village Historic District in Glen Arbor Township, Leelanau County (NRIS 83000882). The file holds two documents. The first is a nomination form prepared in November 1982 by Ron Cockrell, an NPS historian, and Thomas Hensley, an NPS historical architect. The NPS received it in January 1983 [1, PDF p. 1]; [2, PDF p. 34]. The second is additional documentation. Its date of action, 4/19/90, is entered beside a checked box reading "Additional information on a previously-listed district" [2, PDF pp. 15, 34]. The NPS catalog record gives a publication date of 6/24/1983 [3]. Every statement below is the form's account, not an independent finding. The preparers drew on secondary works, interviews, and a 1928 newspaper obituary. Descriptions of condition and ownership date from 1982 or 1989, not today. Port Oneida, the subject of entry 013, lies in the same national lakeshore. The Glen Haven file does not mention it.
The village as the 1983 form tells it
According to the 1983 form, Charles C. McCartey built the Sleeping Bear Inn in 1857 as "the first structure in Glen Haven". He also built a long dock and ran a cordwood fueling station for Great Lakes steamers [1, PDF p. 7]. John Helm opened a general store in 1865 and left for Burdickville in 1867. McCartey built a sawmill on Little Glen Lake in 1868. In 1870 he sold his holdings to the Northern Transit Company of Cleveland, which needed fuel for its 24 vessels [1, PDF p. 7]. The form says that "By 1878" the company had sent 26-year-old David Henry Day to manage the station, and that Day bought Glen Haven from the company "in 1881" [1, PDF p. 7].
The same page opens with a different chronology: "By the mid-1800s the David Henry Day Lumber Company owned all the land, sawmill, and docking facilities" [1, PDF p. 7]. The form does not reconcile the two statements.
The form describes Glen Haven as Day's company town. Rent was deducted from wages. Workers were paid in coupons redeemable at the D. H. Day Store, and Day served as postmaster [1, PDF p. 8]. A locomotive was added to the tramway by 1907 [1, PDF p. 8]. The sawmill closed in 1923, and Day built a canning factory in the mid-1920s [1, PDF p. 9]. The form reports that Day donated 32 acres to the state in 1920 and calls the resulting D. H. Day State Park "the first State park in Michigan history" [1, PDF p. 9]. That claim is the form's own and was not checked for this entry. The form quotes Day's 1928 obituary, which called him "King David of the North Country" [1, PDF p. 10]. The obituary itself was not read.
The 1983 form gives its reason for listing in one sentence: Glen Haven is "an excellent example of a turn-of-the-century company lumbering town" [1, PDF p. 7]. Its period boxes mark "1800-1899" and "1900-", with "1857" as the specific date [1, PDF p. 7].
How the 1990 documentation recast it
The 1990 documentation keeps much of the 1983 narrative, sometimes word for word [2, PDF p. 25]. Its argument is different. It says Glen Haven "has been called a 'company town,' a 'Great Lakes village,' a 'lumber kingdom' and an 'empire,' but it is best described as a company operated steamboat stop" [2, PDF p. 23]. It claims eligibility under Criterion A for Great Lakes maritime activity and Criterion B for Day. It sets the period of significance at 1857-1931, with outdoor recreation c. 1920-1939 [2, PDF p. 22]. The 1931 end date marks the year the steamers PURITAN and MANITOU stopped calling. The form attributes that to "the poor economy and the switch to the automobile" [2, PDF p. 27].
The documentation calls Glen Haven "the best preserved example of a frontier cordwood station/steamboat stop on the eastern shore of Lake Michigan and perhaps the entire Great Lakes" [2, PDF p. 22]. Its footnote says that "No comprehensive survey" exists. The claim rests on a 1989 consultation with the directors of four Lake Michigan maritime museums [2, PDF p. 22].
Contradictions as printed
- Building count. The 1983 form counts "15 historically significant buildings and 2 significant historic sites" [1, PDF p. 2]. The 1990 form counts 12 contributing and 4 non-contributing buildings, plus 2 sites [2, PDF pp. 15-16].
- Wickland and Dean houses. The 1983 form says "It is impossible to determine the precise dates" and that both were built either around Day's death in 1928 "or as late as 1947" [1, PDF p. 9]. The 1990 form cites builder Thomas Dean for 1947 (Wickland) and 1952 (Dean), with the Rude Garage in 1953. It adds that county equalization records date the Wickland House to 1940 [2, PDF pp. 20-21]. All three were moved to non-contributing status.
- Rude House. The 1983 form says it was "built during World War I" [1, PDF p. 9]. The 1990 form lists its date as "unknown—late 19th/early 20th century" and says only that it was "occupied during World War I" [2, PDF pp. 19, 26].
- Tramway length. Both documents describe the grade as running "about three miles" in the inventory [1, PDF p. 5]; [2, PDF p. 20]. Both boundary descriptions give "approximately 2¼-miles" [1, PDF p. 12]; [2, PDF p. 33].
- Cannery origin. The 1983 form says Day built the factory [1, PDF p. 9]. The 1990 form says he "adapted his new warehouse" into it in the early 1920s [2, PDF p. 28].
- Period of significance. The 1983 form marks open-ended century boxes [1, PDF p. 7]. The 1990 form gives 1857-1931 [2, PDF p. 22]. The NPS catalog coding lists periods running to 1950-1974 [3].
Related entries
Single source: one NRHP file (1983 nomination plus 1990 additional documentation), resting on secondary works, interviews and a 1928 obituary. No independent record was read; conditions describe 1982/1989.
Sources
- “Glen Haven Village Historic District, National Register of Historic Places Inventory–Nomination Form for Federal Properties.” National Park Service; prepared by Ron Cockrell and Thomas Hensley; hosted by the National Park Service, NPGallery (NRIS 83000882), dated November 22, 1982; received January 31, 1983. Scan PDF pages 1–14 (the preparers are named in the 1990 documentation’s preparer block, PDF page 34). Nomination file (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19
- “Glen Haven, National Register of Historic Places Registration Form, additional documentation.” Sleeping Bear Preservation Committee (April 14, 1989) and Ron Cockrell (November 6, 1989); in the same NPGallery scan, stamped March 20, 1990; Keeper’s date of action 4/19/90. Same scan, PDF pages 15–34. Same scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15
- “Glen Haven Village Historic District (NRIS 83000882).” National Park Service, NPGallery catalog record, undated catalog record. NPGallery record · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2
Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.