The Disputed County-Seat Vote of 1893: Double v. McQueen
Scope and source
This entry rests on a single source: the Michigan Supreme Court's opinion in Double v. McQueen, decided June 7, 1893 [1, p. 39]. Most of what it reports about election day comes from the respondents' answer. That answer was a set of allegations, some made "upon information and belief." The court stated that "[t]he answer must be taken as true" and ordered the election inspectors to show cause. The opinion contains no response from the inspectors and makes no finding on whether the allegations were accurate [1, pp. 42, 44, 46]. The opinion does not say how the vote was finally counted, whether the county seat moved, or where it went. It does not name the proposed site except by its legal description.
The question put to the voters
In 1893, Justice Long wrote, Montmorency County was made up of six townships: Albert, Briley, Hillman, Montmorency, Rust and Wheatfield [1, p. 40]. On February 24, 1893, a special meeting of the board of supervisors considered moving the county seat "from Hillman to another place nearer the center of the county." The board directed that the question go to the voters at the annual election on April 3 [1, p. 40]. The official ballot carried the proposition to remove the county seat to "the north-west quarter of the south-west quarter of section 12, township 30 north, of range 2 east" [1, p. 42].
The canvass stops
The board met on April 21 to canvass the returns. According to the petition, after Hillman's votes had been canvassed, three supervisors refused to go further. They were James H. McQueen of Rust, Andrew Dickie of Montmorency and William Murphy of Hillman. The other three tried and failed to continue, and the board adjourned until July 5, 1893 [1, pp. 40–41]. Thomas Double, the relator, asked the Supreme Court to order the board to finish the count [1, pp. 40–41]. The three supervisors answered that they had not refused, and that the adjournment was meant to allow a full investigation [1, pp. 41, 44].
According to their answer, Hillman's returns showed 6 votes for removal and 117 against. The board suspended its canvass when it reached Albert township, after reading a protest and affidavits about Albert's returns [1, p. 43].
What the answer alleged about Albert township
The respondents' account of Albert is the heart of the case, and it is an account, not a finding. They stated "upon information and belief" that at least 80 votes against removal had been marked on the official ballots. Most of those votes, they said, came from residents of the village of Lewiston, about nine miles from the polling place, who voted "almost to a man before noon" [1, p. 42].
The answer alleged that these voters were never told to use a separate ballot box. After they had gone home, it said, the inspectors produced a small box and ballots printed "For the removal of the county seat,—Yes." The answer said the relator was one of those inspectors [1, pp. 42–43]. It alleged that 23 voters from the northerly part of the township then cast those ballots "under an understanding with the election inspectors." It also alleged that the inspectors treated the 80 or more official-ballot votes as illegal and returned only the 23 [1, p. 43]. The answer further claimed that in Briley, and also in Wheatfield, voters had a chance to vote twice on the question [1, p. 43].
What the court did
The court declined to issue the writ, because the supervisors said they would canvass on July 5 [1, p. 44]. At counsel's request it addressed other questions. Taking the answer as true, the court said its facts "would change the result of the election," because on the returns as made the majority favored removal [1, pp. 44–45]. The court said that, under the statute, the board's determination and recorded canvass result from an election "regularly held" would be "conclusive for all purposes" [1, p. 45]. Votes cast on the official ballot "should not be excluded by the inspectors," and "[t]he voters of that township cannot be thus disfranchised" [1, p. 46].
The court treated the answer as a petition and ordered the inspectors of Albert, Briley and Wheatfield to show cause [1, p. 46].
Where the record ends
The opinion ends with that order. It does not report what the inspectors answered, what the July canvass found, or whether any removal followed. Those answers would need other records, which were not examined for this entry.
Single source: this entry rests on one court opinion. Most of its account of election day comes from the respondents' answer, which the court took as true for its ruling while making no finding on whether it was accurate.
Sources
- Thomas Double v. James H. McQueen, Andrew Dickie, and William W. Murphy, 96 Mich. 39 (Michigan Supreme Court, opinion of Long, J.; Michigan Reports, vol. 96, pp. 39–46, William D. Fuller, reporter, Chicago: Callaghan & Co., 1893; official scan hosted by the Michigan Courts, argued May 31, decided June 7, 1893). Printed pp. 39–46 used (PDF pages 95–102 of the scan). Official scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18
Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.