Freight Cars on Open Water: Elberta and the Car Ferry City of Milwaukee
Scope
This entry rests on one source: the National Historic Landmark nomination for the car ferry City of Milwaukee, part of the National Park Service's maritime heritage theme study of large vessels. William Herd, historian at the Northwest Michigan Maritime Museum, prepared it on May 18, 1990 [1, p. 19]. It gives the ship's location as the Marine Terminal Railyard, East Slip, Elberta, Benzie County [1, p. 1]. The NPGallery catalog lists the counties as Benzie and Manistee, but this entry follows the nomination, which names Benzie only. The certification block on this copy is blank, and NPGallery gives a publication date of December 14, 1990. The nomination's account of 1892 rests on secondary works it cites, including a 1981 history of the Ann Arbor car ferries by Arthur and Lucy Frederickson [1, p. 16]. No record from 1892 was read for this entry. Everything here is as of 1990, and the entry makes no claim about where the ship is now.
The experiment of 1892
In 1892, the nomination says, the Toledo, Ann Arbor and North Michigan Railroad was "extended to Frankfort and Betsie Bay." Its president, James Ashley, envisioned a car ferry to carry cars across Lake Michigan [1, p. 12]. Then, "On November 24, 1892, a bold experiment began at South Frankfort, Michigan, to transport loaded freight cars across the open water" of the Great Lakes [1, p. 7]; [1, p. 8].
Frank E. Kirby was called on to design the new ferry. It had an enclosed bow and was loaded from the stern. Its wooden hull was sheathed with steel to 4 feet above the waterline, and it could carry 24 cars [1, p. 12]. To keep the cars from shifting, an extra rail was laid two feet outside the regular rail, with jacks, clamps, chains and turnbuckles to fasten each car to the ship [1, p. 13].
The nomination says shippers refused to trust cargo to the first trip. Finally a coal shipper under contract to the railroad was persuaded to send "four carloads of coal on the first voyage." The first two ferries were named Ann Arbor No. 1 and Ann Arbor No. 2 [1, p. 13]. The nomination does not say which of the two made the first crossing.
The fleet
By the nomination's count, 39 vessels were eventually built for this service. At its peak the fleet used 14 vessels "to transport 14 full freight trains a day across Lake Michigan alone" [1, p. 8].
City of Milwaukee
The Grand Trunk's car ferry Milwaukee "disappeared in a storm with all 53 persons on board in October 1929." The railroad ordered a replacement, City of Milwaukee, the last of six ferries built to Manitowoc plans [1, p. 15]. Manitowoc Shipbuilding Company built her in 1931 as Hull No. 261, official number 230448. She is a twin-screw steamer whose two triple-expansion engines together made 2,700 horsepower, and her car deck holds 22 modern-size freight cars [1, p. 3].
As cargo declined in the Depression, she became the Grand Trunk's "spare boat" and was often leased to other railroads [1, p. 8]; [1, p. 15]. Her coal-fired boilers were converted to oil in 1947. The Grand Trunk Western ended car-ferry operation in 1978. The State of Michigan then bought the ship for the Ann Arbor Railroad, and she stayed in service until 1982. The state later transferred her to the City of Frankfort, which passed her to the Society for the Preservation of the Steamship City of Milwaukee for a museum ship [1, p. 15]; [1, p. 16].
Where the service began
In 1990 the nomination called City of Milwaukee "the sole surviving example of a pre-1940, 'classic' period Great Lakes Car Ferry" and marked her significance as national [1, p. 8]; [1, p. 7]. It placed her at "the Marine Terminal Railyard of the Ann Arbor Railroad at Elberta, Michigan, where crosslake ferry service began nearly 100 years ago" [1, p. 8]. The nomination names South Frankfort as the place of the 1892 start and Elberta as the ship's 1990 berth. It never says in so many words that the two names refer to one place [1, p. 7]; [1, p. 8]. Another page calls the dock "the Arbor Railroad Terminal in Elberta" [1, p. 3].
Single 1990 National Historic Landmark nomination. The 1892 account rests on secondary works the nomination cites; no record from 1892 was read. The certification block on this copy is blank. No claim is made about where the ship is now.
Sources
- Herd, William. “Maritime Heritage of the United States NHL Theme Study, Large Vessels: City of Milwaukee (Car Ferry), National Register of Historic Places Registration Form (NPS Form 10-900).” National Register of Historic Places, prepared by William Herd, Northwest Michigan Maritime Museum; hosted by the National Park Service, NPGallery (NRIS 90002221), dated May 18, 1990, 19 pages; NPGallery publication date December 14, 1990; certification block on this copy is blank. Page references are the form's typed page numbers, which match the PDF pages. Registration form (PDF) · NPGallery record · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20 ↩21 ↩22
Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.