Bay View's Terraces and Cottages, as Recorded in 1986
Scope
This entry describes Bay View, in Emmet County, as one document recorded it: a National Register of Historic Places Inventory–Nomination Form prepared by Ellen Weiss and dated 4/86 [1, PDF p. 4]. It reports what that form says, attributed to the form. It is not an independent history of Bay View's founding, and it does not describe the place as it is today. Where the form disagrees with itself, the disagreement is noted rather than resolved.
The setting
The form describes Bay View as "a religiously oriented summer community of 435 cottages, three hotels, and 20 association buildings." It is set on the northern half of a wooded tract of 337.78 acres. The land, in the form's words, cascades "in natural terraces from a 200-foot elevation down to Little Traverse Bay" [1, PDF p. 5]. The form records the same acreage for the nominated property [1, PDF p. 4].
Weiss's description follows the approach into the plan. At the entry, the form says, a gently curving road leads up behind a row of cottages into Fairview Park, a green "defined by two long crescents" of houses on fifty-foot lots [1, PDF p. 5]. The southern arc, Fairview Avenue, lies at the bottom of "a twenty to twenty-five foot curving ridge." Another row of cottages stands on that ridge, served by Glendale Avenue, "a sinuously curving street at a higher level" [1, PDF p. 5]. The ridge figure describes one rise within the site, not the tract's overall 200-foot elevation.
The form calls this "a sample of the planning style: a series of terraces rising in steps above the bay, each terrace a platform for cottages" [1, PDF p. 5]. It also describes cottages facing onto parks, curving roads, and planted islands at many intersections. Narrow sidewalks run apart from the roadbeds, often above the paving or across a wide parkway. In places such as Block 41 and the part of Block 19 called Evergreen Park, "the sidewalk diverges completely from the road," crossing low ground used as parkland [1, PDF p. 5]. East of Fairview Park the form describes a second, larger open space, Tabernacle Park, which it calls a natural amphitheater [1, PDF p. 5].
Three cottage types
The inventory describes three two-story cottage types, generally with two-tiered porches; it notes variations, including a Type 2 dormer in place of the upper porch [1, PDF p. 21]:
- Type 1: an end-gable entrance, with the gable roof extending over the two-tiered porch. The form counts 46.
- Type 2: a flank-gable entry with a perpendicular gable on the center of the flank side and a symmetrical facade. The form counts 57.
- Type 3: a "T" plan with perpendicular gables and a two-tiered porch on the gable end of the foot of the "T". The form counts 50.
A note says the totals "include slight variations or those which were later modified" [1, PDF p. 21]. The three types do not account for every building.
Counts that disagree
The form gives more than one count. The inventory opens by listing "458 buildings, 436 contributing and 22 non-contributing," on "forty-five irregularly-shaped blocks," plus one contributing and one non-contributing structure [1, PDF p. 9]. The significance statement refers to "437 contributing buildings" [1, PDF p. 22]. The form also gives differing construction dates for some buildings in different sections. Loud Hall, for example, is dated 1897 in the description and 1887 in the inventory [1, PDF pp. 6, 9]. This entry reports those conflicting dates without choosing between them; it does not adopt either as Loud Hall's construction date.
Who designed the plan?
The form interprets Bay View's plan as "an early example of the principles of romantic landscape design applied to subdivisions" [1, PDF p. 23]. On authorship it is cautious. It says Samuel O. Knapp of Jackson, "the Methodist layman who found the terraced site during a camping trip, may have designed the Bay View plan" [1, PDF p. 23]. That is the form's suggestion, not an established fact. Settling it would need records such as a signed plan or association minutes, which were not examined for this entry.
Single source: this entry rests on one document, a 1986 nomination form, and reports what that form says. It is not an independent history of Bay View and does not describe the place as it is today.
Sources
- Weiss, Ellen. “Bay View (Bay View Association), National Register of Historic Places Inventory–Nomination Form.” National Register of Historic Places, prepared by Ellen Weiss; hosted by the National Park Service, NPGallery (NRIS 72000613), prepared April 1986, 28 pages. PDF pages 4–6, 9 and 21–23 used; page references are PDF page positions, not the form's own continuation-sheet numbers. Nomination form (PDF) · NPGallery record · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15
Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.