The Resolution of August 29, 2000: 46th Circuit Trial Court v. Crawford County (2006)
Scope
This entry rests on one source: the Michigan Supreme Court's reported decision in 46th Circuit Trial Court v. Crawford County, 476 Mich. 131–179 (2006), with the court's later amendment order [1]. It reports what the opinions say. Where the lead opinion and the dissent describe the record differently, both accounts are given. The dispute involved three counties served by one court. Crawford County and the Crawford County Board of Commissioners were named defendants. The reporter's syllabus lists Kalkaska County as a defendant; the lead opinion says Kalkaska moved to intervene [1, pp. 131, 138]. The trial court's opinion, the Court of Appeals opinion, the county resolutions themselves and any later proceedings were not read.
One court, three counties
The 46th Circuit Court served Otsego, Crawford and Kalkaska counties. Under a Supreme Court administrative order of 1996, it and the district and probate courts in those counties joined a demonstration project designed to evaluate consolidating their functions into a single entity, the 46th Circuit Trial Court. Otsego County was its control unit [1, pp. 135–136].
In the summer of 2000, according to the lead opinion, the chief judge asked court employees to accept a less favorable prescription drug and health plan and to give up longevity pay. "In return for this concession," he agreed to seek an enhanced pension plan and a new retiree health care plan funded by the counties [1, p. 136]. The Otsego and Kalkaska boards passed resolutions agreeing to it [1, p. 136].
The Crawford resolution
On August 29, 2000, the Crawford County Board of Commissioners passed its resolution. The opinion reproduces it. It capped the county's Blue Cross/Blue Shield medical supplement payment per individual for 2000 at $4,087, rising 4 percent a year [1, p. 136]. That same afternoon, the lead opinion says, the chief judge told the board's chairwoman that the first-year premium had been miscalculated. The two agreed on $5,763 instead, but "the Crawford board never amended the resolution" [1, p. 137]. Kalkaska and Otsego signed the contract that followed. Crawford refused, citing concern about "a sizeable unfunded liability" [1, p. 137]. On December 4, 2000, the chief judge put the plans in place by order [1, p. 137].
The opinions disagree about what happened next. The lead opinion says Kalkaska rescinded its approval about a year after the order, and that Otsego then paid the full cost [1, p. 137]. The dissent, relying on the trial judge's findings, says Kalkaska rescinded one week after the order, and Crawford rescinded its acceptance of the retiree health fund on February 1, 2001 [1, p. 173].
The lawsuit
The Trial Court sued to compel funding. A visiting judge, Dennis C. Kolenda, was assigned from outside the three counties. He found the benefits "reasonable and necessary" and held that Crawford's August 29 resolution created a contract. The Court of Appeals affirmed [1, pp. 131, 138–139].
The Supreme Court divides 4–3
The Supreme Court reversed and sent the case back for judgment in favor of the defendant counties [1, pp. 133, 161]. Justice Markman wrote the lead opinion, joined by Chief Justice Taylor and Justice Young. Justice Corrigan concurred. Justice Weaver dissented, joined by Justices Cavanagh and Kelly [1, pp. 132–133, 161, 179].
The lead opinion held that a court seeking to compel funding must prove by clear and convincing evidence that the funding is "reasonable and necessary" [1, p. 149]. It found no showing that "even one person" had left over the benefits, and found that the court was still functioning [1, pp. 150, 160]. It also adopted an older Court of Appeals formula: funding at a "serviceable" level means a function "will be carried out in a barely adequate manner" [1, p. 150]. That "barely adequate" standard was the view of three justices only. Justice Corrigan declined to join that part [1, pp. 161–162]. The dissent observed that an opinion without four signatures "is not binding precedent" [1, pp. 164–165].
On the contract, the lead opinion said that because a county already has a constitutional duty to fund its courts, such a contract "would appear to fail for lack of consideration." It added that there was no meeting of the minds with Crawford, because the resolution authorized a $4,087 first-year cap while the actual cap was $5,763, and the board "never voted on any amended resolution" [1, p. 158]. Since all three counties had to agree, the other contracts failed too [1, p. 159]. Justice Corrigan joined this reasoning [1, pp. 161–162]. Any increase in benefits, the lead opinion concluded, must come from the county boards, "not by judicial order" [1, p. 161].
The dissent
Justice Weaver wrote that Judge Kolenda, after a six-day hearing and about 5,500 pages of exhibits, did not clearly err [1, p. 162]. She said the lead opinion "mischaracterizes the record," pointing to the court administrator's testimony that "six left for wages and benefits" [1, pp. 168–169]. The lead opinion answered that he could not identify even one of them who had told him they were leaving for better retirement plans [1, p. 150 n. 9].
A note on the docket number
The case heading prints "Docket No. 128878" [1, p. 131]. The August 21, 2006 order amending one sentence of the opinion prints "No. 128788" [1, p. 1201]. This entry does not resolve the difference and cites the case by its report.
Single source: this entry rests on one reported decision with a lead opinion, a concurrence and a dissent that disagree about the record. The county resolutions, trial opinion and later proceedings were not read.
Sources
- 46th Circuit Trial Court v. Crawford County, 476 Mich. 131 (Michigan Supreme Court, lead opinion by Markman, J., concurrence by Corrigan, J., dissent by Weaver, J.; Michigan Reports, vol. 476, pp. 131–179, and “Opinion Amended August 21, 2006,” p. 1201, Danilo Anselmo, Reporter of Decisions; Thomson West, 2007; copyright Michigan Supreme Court; official PDF hosted by the Michigan Courts, decided July 28, 2006; opinion amended August 21, 2006). Printed pp. 131–179 (PDF pages 185–233) and p. 1201 (PDF page 759) used. Official PDF · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20 ↩21 ↩22 ↩23 ↩24 ↩25 ↩26 ↩27 ↩28
Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.